If you’re reading this, congratulations 🎉—you’ve made it past the first moat and landed a coveted 43North Accelerator interview! It’s a big deal. You’ve already beat out thousands of startups for your shot at $1 million, direct access to A-list investors, and a front-row seat in Buffalo’s rising startup scene.
But let’s be real: getting the interview is just the start. The process ahead is an endurance test for founder poise, transparency, and your ability to think (and pitch) under real heat 🔥. The questions get tough. The scrutiny is direct. And one bad answer—especially about Buffalo—can be fatal.
So, whether you’re prepping for the virtual semi-finals or anxiously booking flights ✈️ for the on-stage finals, this is your no-BS, founder-to-founder guide. We’ll break down what actually happens, what judges really want, and how top founders prepare, based on direct public sources, real founder stories, and everything the 43North selection team does (and doesn’t) tell you upfront.💹🌟
Related Posts
The 43North Accelerator Interview Process: What Actually Happens, and What It Signals
This isn’t just another pitch meeting—it’s a full-on audition in front of an audience that includes top-tier investors, judges, and Buffalo’s startup community. You’ll need more than a good deck: this is about poise, pressure, and proof that you’re ready to lead from center stage.
Many founders underestimate just how intense, performative, and public the 43North Accelerator interview can be. Here’s the flow:
- 🎥 Semi-Finals (Virtual):
You’ll join a video call for a 15–20 minute session. Expect a classic pitch + Q&A format, but judges will probe closely on weak points. The tone is professional but conversational, with the goal of “vetting the fundamentals.” Your answers decide if you get flown to the finals. - 🎭 Finals (In-Person, Buffalo):
This is not your average Demo Day. Think: packed theater, bright stage lights, hundreds in the audience, and a panel of celebrity judges (think: Tim Draper, Soraya Darabi, David Friend). You’ll have a timed 4–5 minute public pitch, followed by an intense, direct Q&A—also timed. The show is livestreamed and decisions are announced that night.
(Expect several days in Buffalo: due diligence, media, and hang time with the local ecosystem. Yes, they are watching how you interact everywhere.) - 🧑⚖️ Who Judges:
For semi-finals, you get VCs, operators, subject experts, and past 43North winners (judge bios are private). For finals, it’s a headline-worthy panel—national investors, exited founders, Fortune 500 execs. Each asks questions from their domain: tech, go-to-market, fundraising, and always, Why Buffalo?
What This Means:
You’re not just selling your product—you’re auditioning as an out-front, coachable founder who can handle investor pressure and commit to Buffalo, in full view of the ecosystem. Treat every Q&A as “founder due diligence.” Arrogance or vague answers are instant red flags.
What 43North Judges Are Really Asking (And How to Nail the Answers)
This section is where the interview game gets real. Every question they ask is a window into deeper founder signals: clarity, grit, coachability, and strategic thinking. Here’s how to spot what’s really being tested—and how to give the kind of answers that stick with judges.
The Criteria Behind Every Question of 43North Accelerator Interview
Beneath the surface, every 43North Accelerator interview boils down to four core filters:
1️⃣ Is this founder uniquely suited and coachable?
Judges are betting on you, not just your metrics. They want grit, humility, deep domain knowledge, and a calm presence when challenged.
2️⃣ Does this company have venture-scale growth potential?
Revenue, early customer traction, aggressive growth plans, and a non-lifestyle business model. This is not the place for coasting.
3️⃣ Are you committed to Buffalo (with receipts)?
If you fumble or drop a generic “we’ll move because you say so,” you will lose out. “Why Buffalo?” is a critical dealbreaker.
4️⃣ Are your answers direct, consistent, and honest?
Dodging, flustered hand-waving, or providing conflicting numbers is a killer. If you don’t know something, admit it and show your data-driven process.
Common 43North Accelerator Interview Questions & What They’re Really Testing
Here’s what to expect (and what’s under the hood):
| Question What They’re Really Testing | |
|---|---|
| “What problem are you solving and for whom?” | Are you hunting a big, genuine pain point with a sharp insight? |
| “What makes your team the one to win?” | Is there founder/product/problem fit—and are you coachable under fire? |
| “What’s your MRR/ARR/growth rate?” | Do you know your numbers, and does your traction back your pitch? |
| “What’s your CAC, LTV, and churn?” | Is your model scalable, with evidence? If you hesitate, the trust erodes. |
| “Who is your competition and why are you defensible?” | Say “no competitors” and they’ll instantly tune out. They want proof you’ve truly mapped the market and built a moat. |
| “Why Buffalo? What’s your plan after moving?” | This is the non-negotiable. Tie your answer to local industry, schools, talent, research, customers, or partnerships—and show you’ve already done the legwork. “We Googled a bit” won’t cut it. |
Pro Tip: Be as specific as possible on “Why Buffalo.” Mention local university labs, talent pipelines, relevant manufacturing clusters, or pre-scouted office space. The more concrete, the better. One finalist put it best:
“We researched the polymer science programs at UB, studied the region’s manufacturing legacy, and even identified industrial parks we could grow into.”
— [43North winner, paraphrased]
“Survive and Thrive” Checklist: Tactics Top Founders Swear By
Getting the details right means grinding through the real prep work. Here’s a time-tested, founder-sourced action list—use it as your interview insurance policy 👇
| Prep Move | Why It Matters | Tips From Winners |
|---|---|---|
| 💬 Pitch, Rehearse, Repeat | Time is tight; muscle memory shows. | Practice in front of strangers—not just friends. Stay within time. Record yourself. |
| 🔥 Mock Q&A “Murder Board” | Arm yourself for hardball questions. | Recruit mentors to grill you on weak points (not just obvious ones). Document every possible tough question. |
| 🎯 Judge Recon | Each judge has angles & pet questions. | Watch previous 43North Finals on YouTube; research likely domains of expertise. |
| 📍 Buffalo Deep Dive | Prove your “Why Buffalo” answer runs deep. | Identify industry clusters, university partners, potential hires. If possible, reach out to Buffalo contacts beforehand. |
| 📊 Numbers Drill | Fumbling metrics is a dealbreaker. | Know CAC, LTV, MRR/ARR, burn, and sales pipeline cold. Don’t round up or guess. |
| 🤝 Internal Founder Alignment | Contradictions destroy credibility. | Assign clear roles (CEO on vision/traction, CTO on tech), rehearse smooth handoffs in Q&A. |
| 🎤 On-Stage Presence | Finals are as much theater as pitch. | Practice eye contact, thank judges for questions, and remain poised—even if challenged. |
Takeaway:
Don’t just wing it. Past winners say the intensity of practice is itself transformative, and “the process to prepare for the finals was as valuable as winning the competition itself.”
Founder Missteps That Tank the 43North Accelerator Interview(And How to Avoid Them)
Plenty of great startups never make it past the 43North Accelerator interview—not due to product, but to missteps in the hot seat. Don’t be one of them:
- ⚠️ The “Generic Buffalo Pitch”
Judges see through surface-level research. Be ready to cite specific Buffalo resources, contacts, and plans. - ⏱️ Rambling or Over Time
The clock is your enemy. Running long or failing to answer directly = instant point deduction. - ❌ Evading, Defending, or Bluffing
If you’re challenged, don’t get defensive. Acknowledge, address, move on. - 😤 Arrogance or Uncoachability
Confidence is encouraged. Swagger is punished. Show you’re listening—and that you’ll grow with feedback. - 📉 Inconsistent Numbers
If your answers on traction, burn, or projections don’t line up, you’ll lose credibility fast. - 🧑💼 Not Having the CEO Present
Only founders—especially the CEO—should be the face of the pitch. A disconnect here is a major red flag.
What Founders Miss: Even informal interactions in Buffalo (hotel lobby chats, program mixers) are being observed. “They are watching how you interact with staff, other founders, and the community,” as one finalist put it. This is part of their due diligence.
Common 43North Accelerator Interview Questions & Gold-Standard Dos/Don’ts
Here’s a quickfire table of classic questions and how to handle them under pressure:
| Question | Do: | Don’t: |
|---|---|---|
| What’s your traction to date? | Give numbers, cohorts, trends. | Handwave, overstate, or vague “interest.” |
| What’s your biggest risk? | Acknowledge then address mitigation. | Say “no risks” or dodge the question. |
| Who are your direct competitors? | List a few, explain why you win. | Claim “we have no competition.” |
| Why relocate to Buffalo? | Tie answer to real Buffalo resources and plans. | Give generic “we’ll move if we have to.” |
| What’s your plan to build in Buffalo? | Reference hiring, local partnerships, strategic reasons. | Focus on remote work or “virtual presence.” |
Pro Tip:
Pause before answering tough or surprising questions. A breath signals confidence. If you don’t know, say, “I don’t have that exact figure—here’s our tracking method, and I can follow up.” Honesty > bluffing every time.
Beyond the Pitch: Fit, Follow-up, and Founder Realities
The interview doesn’t end when you step off stage or close your Zoom window. What happens next can shape your long-term standing with 43North—and Buffalo itself. From post-pitch etiquette to residency expectations, this is where great founders separate from good ones.
The Final Cut & What Happens Next
- 📬 Decision Timing:
- ⏳ Semi-finals: Expect a waiting period; winners are announced weeks later.
- 🏆 Finals: Winners are announced live—no suspenseful email. If chosen, you’ll need to commit quickly, relocate, and get active in Buffalo (51% of staff for at least a year).
- ✉️ Follow-up:
- After semi-finals, a short, professional thank-you email is polite (no extra pitching—just gratitude).
- If you’re rejected: Seek feedback if offered, grow the business, and consider reapplying. Many winners failed in their first attempt.
- 🌱 Long-Term Expectations:
- You’re joining a community, not just bagging a check. 43North expects visibility, mentorship of other founders, and real engagement in Buffalo’s ecosystem—during and after your residency.
Inclusion and Buffalo’s “Genuine Interest” Rule
43North is building more than a portfolio—it’s building Buffalo as a startup powerhouse.
That means:
- 🌍 They prize diversity in founders—background, gender, ethnicity—and encourage those underrepresented in tech to apply.
- 🗣️ In the Buffalo scene, reputation travels fast. Humility and a collaborative spirit count, both on and off the stage.
- 💖 The biggest unwritten rule: show a genuine (not just transactional) desire to be part of Buffalo’s comeback story.
Final Thoughts: Your 43North Accelerator Interview Is a Gateway
Past winners agree: the 43North Accelerator Interview is one of the most intense, transformative moments 🔥 for any founder—whether you bring home the $1M check or not.
- 🧠 Take the preparation seriously—as seriously as the finals. No stage is a breeze.
- 📣 Focus on clarity, numbers, and honest storytelling. One shaky answer can break the deal, but one authentic insight can win judges’ hearts (and votes).
- 🏙️ Don’t “fake” Buffalo commitment. Judges want more than a move—they want a true ambassador for the ecosystem.
Above all, remember:
“The process to prepare for the finals was as valuable as winning the competition itself.” 💡 Every grilling, every awkward question, is making you a sharper, more investable founder. That’s how you win here—and everywhere else you pitch.
So: breathe, prep, and go light up that 43North stage. The spotlight’s yours 🎤.
